Swiss War Materiel and Arms Exports

Back to the list

The collapsed tank deal for Khomeini’s Iran

Goods category: War materiel

Ruhollah Khomeini, 1964; historical postcard.

Public Domain laut Commons (PD-1996)

In July 1981, Swiss and German intermediaries agreed with London-based Botco Ltd., later Wedemex, to supply 50 US M48A5 main battle tanks to Iran. The buyer company was headed by Sadegh Tabatabai. The contract value was US$67 million, then around 130 million Swiss francs. Around 70 per cent, or 90 million Swiss francs, was paid; no tanks were delivered. Forged shipping and insurance documents played a role in the payment. An initial trial before the Zurich High Court was halted after two days in March 1985; the court requested further evidence. In November 1989, Walter Gnädinger, Bretscher and Roland Huber appeared in court again. Bretscher denied knowing about the forgeries; Gnädinger said the buyer had been aware of them. Huber’s defence relied on good faith. Prosecutors requested prison terms of six years and four months for Gnädinger, six years for Bretscher and six months for Huber. In early November 1989, the High Court sentenced Gnädinger and Bretscher to two years in prison each for document forgery. It acquitted both of fraud: in the majority’s view, the Iranian purchaser’s participation in the fictitious deal could not be ruled out. Huber was acquitted of document forgery and received compensation of 3’000 Swiss francs. He had received seven million Swiss francs for his brokerage. No later appeal decision or confirmation that this judgment became final is documented.

Effect of the proposed War Materiel Act revision

Under the new Article 22b, the Federal Council could depart from all the licensing criteria in Article 22a under vaguely defined ‘exceptional circumstances’. The public would not have to be informed. The Federal Council could add Iran to Annex 2 by amending the War Materiel Ordinance. This would remove the exclusion criterion based on participation in an armed conflict and make approval the rule. The Federal Council could refuse a licence only in exceptional cases. Article 18 paragraph 1 would abolish non-re-export declarations in the vast majority of cases. Weapons for Iran could thus easily be supplied through a subsidiary or intermediary in a third country.

Countries

Conflicts

Companies

Time period

Tank deal in 1981; trials in 1985 and November 1989

Sources

  • Blick, 07.11.1989, S. 7: Sie verkauften Panzer, die es gar nicht gab (Viktor Dammann)
  • Tages-Anzeiger, 02.11.1989, S. 17 (Archivvermerk): Ein Riesenschwindel oder ein Komplott — Phantasiepanzer an den Iran verkauft (Rolf Gilgen)
  • Blick, 08.11.1989, S. 2 (Archivvermerk): Panzer-Prozess: Geschäftsleute 2 Jahre hinter Gitter (Viktor Dammann)