Swiss War Materiel and Arms Exports

Back to the list

Circumvention deal: weapons for Kazakhstan via New Zealand

Goods category: War materiel

In 2008, SECO rejected the direct delivery of six precision rifles and eighteen grenade launchers to Kazakhstan’s Arystan anti-terrorist unit. In 2009, it approved the export with a New Zealand company named as the end recipient. The weapons nevertheless reached Kazakhstan. On 10 December 2014, a summary penalty order was issued against the Swiss arms dealer responsible for false statements in the licensing procedure, imposing a fine of 3’000 Swiss francs and confiscation of 30’000 Swiss francs in profits. Following intervening court proceedings, the order became final when the objection was withdrawn in March 2017. The Federal Supreme Court confirmed this in 2018 and ruled that a subsequent amendment to the confiscation order was inadmissible. An internal investigation cleared the SECO employee involved of disciplinary wrongdoing in 2017. Decision SK.2016.20 documents the dealer’s withdrawal of the objection on 1 March 2017 and the closure of the court proceedings on 3 March 2017. The additional amendment to the confiscation order made in that decision was overturned by the Federal Supreme Court in 2018; the withdrawal and the finality of the summary penalty order remained in place. In a report dated 27 February 2017, Andreas Maurer explicitly linked the Kazakhstan/New Zealand case to Karl Brügger and Thun-based B&T. This identification of the company and individual comes from the media report; the cited court decisions anonymise those involved. The Federal Supreme Court’s 2018 judgment remains authoritative for the final outcome of the proceedings.

Effect of the proposed War Materiel Act revision

Under the new Article 22b, the Federal Council could depart from all the licensing criteria in Article 22a under vaguely defined ‘exceptional circumstances’. The public would not have to be informed. The Federal Council could add Kazakhstan to Annex 2 by amending the War Materiel Ordinance. This would remove the exclusion criterion based on participation in an armed conflict and make approval the rule. The Federal Council could refuse a licence only in exceptional cases. Article 18 paragraph 1 would abolish non-re-export declarations in the vast majority of cases. Weapons for Kazakhstan could thus easily be supplied through a subsidiary or intermediary in a third country. Spain could serve as a third country, having, according to SIPRI, supplied substantial quantities of war materiel to Kazakhstan in recent years (186 million TIV).

Countries

Companies

Time period

Refusal in 2008; delivery in 2009; proceedings in 2014–2018

Sources